What the jury wants to see
During one of The Bobs’ jury conferences, a jury member heard about an initiative in a language he couldn’t understand but still reached to the immediate conclusion, “That’s amazing. It’s got my vote. That’s exactly what we need in my country!”
That (true) story sums up what The Bobs are about: Finding out about something being done – sometimes far away and in a different language – that would be perfect for the place you live.
And, in a nutshell, that’s what the criteria are for selecting the winners. There are, of course, other aspects that come into play, but it’s the international, multilingual nature of The Bobs and its international jury that set it apart from other online awards and the winners will all have aspects that translate well to other cultures and across language barriers.
Depending on the category, some factors will be given more weight than others. Content, added value, design and functionality will all come under discussion during the judging process.
Here are the bullet points the jury will use in making their evaluations:
The Big Idea
- The notion behind the site, project or initiative and its implementation
- Relevance to society at large
- Audience-appropriate explanatory tone
- Language style
- Ongoing engagement with topics and users
- Transparency and authenticity
- Visual originality and skill at taking advantage of the possibilities offered by the Internet
- Site’s novelty / uniqueness
Jury members decide
This is not a comprehensive list of what jury members will take into account when evaluating projects. The online world is constantly changing and developing. It’s up to The Bobs jury panel to use these points as guidelines and the basis for their evaluations, but it’s up to the jury member to make the final decision which nominee deserves the title “Best of” in its category.
Jury members will consider: whether projects are impressive or innovative enough to have an influence beyond the language(s) they have been created in, whether the people behind a site or project are in a dangerous – or even life-threatening – situation and whether international recognition would help them or promote their work, is it an innovative project whose idea and success could be recreated in another language region. Projects that clearly answer “yes” to the above questions are excellent candidates for The Bobs.
Sites with racist, pornographic, sexist, xenophobic, anti-Semitic, discriminating or insulting content will not be allowed in the contest. Religious fundamentalism, hate speech, political extremism, and calls for violence will not be permitted to take part in the contest.
Users’ Choice criteria
The winners of the User Awards will be determined by votes cast online for each of the finalists in each language-specific category. The blog, project or initiative with the most votes wins.